Saturday, June 12, 2021

Lasalle Second Edition: First Playthrough - The Battle of Eselbach

 The usual suspects, Ken, Dave, and I, got together last week at Ken's house to play through our first game of the second edition of Sam Mustafa's "Lasalle" tactical Napoleonic rules.  A completely revamped game, Lasalle features an innovative turn and initiative sequence, governed by player decision and momentum points, and a very straightforward combat sequence which we all agreed was much fun and quite decisive.

Same body, but different engine under the hood!

We played the introductory "Battle of Eselbach, 1809" scenario from the Honour website.  Yours truly played the French, and Dave played the Austrians, with Ken as umpire and ref (although none is needed for a game).  We played with Ken's outstanding 15mm collection - always a treat!  This is a meeting engagement to seize a village in the center of the table.

Ken (r) and Dave (l) at the table.  The French coming from upper right.

My plan is to deploy a French brigade to cover my left flank and the creek crossing, while another Brigade swings wide around the right and captures the village.  My Cavalry, all light, will swing widely around and capture Dave's baggage train, costing him 2 momentum points per turn (you get 1 per brigade, 2 for your baggage, and if you so desire, a variable amount from your commanding general).

All is prepared - French assault columns ready to move out and dash toward Eselbach!

My left-most Brigade deploys to cover the creek and my left flank.

Dave has a similar plan in mind and will send a Brigade straight to the town, while another swings around my flank!  Let's see what happens when we get stuck in!

Long lines of Austrians trudging up to the front!

Smart French Battlelines deployed for action!  We'll open fire on those KaiserLicks!

I told you Ken's figures were excellent to game with!!  

The Battlelines are drawn around Eselbach!  The Austrians enter the village but do not "Garrison" it.  Note the French columns top-center "Swinging around".

French Cavalry on a wild end-run!

Off the bat, each turn is chock-full of decision making.  Youre not just sitting around waiting for your opponents to finish.  Instead, you have a decision to make if an action occurs within close proximity to your troops, enabling you to perform an action if you would like to.  There is much leeway in the actions you may perform, however you may not have the momentum points left to do so.  It's an elegant system and it just works.  


Hard fighting around Eselbach as both sides engage in a murderous firefight!

Thick musket smoke conceals the positions of both sides as they trade fire across the Esel.

Epic fighting amongst battle hardened battalions.

The slogging firefight is certainly going my way at the creek and I'm pleased with how the firing is going but I'm not able to get my assault columns into range fast enough due to their proximity to the enemy and my own troops.  It's gotten too crowded!  While interpenetration is allowed, it's expensive and costs you another momentum to get it sorted out!

Dave's Cavalry facing the REAR of my troops!  This will not end well for me!

Fighting to get a toe-hold in Eselbach.  Dave's left battalion has almost had it here after turns of trading volleys through the cornfield, but they're keeping my assault columns from assaulting the village.

Close proximity to the enemy you may only move 2 BW.  Ugh!  Slow going.

You can almost hear the drums and the chanting of  Vive l’Empereur
 
More Austrians on the ropes!  Dave's lead battalion in a huge brigade mass formation takes grapeshot going into an assault.

Dave's holding onto the town well and I'm trying to crack an opening to get in!  Do I have the turns left to do it?

Beautiful picture!
Finally I get my cavalry engaged and they tear into the flank of Dave's depleted left flank Battalion and are destroyed.  It's a perfect setup for an assault, but Dave's Battalion in the village, which he's kept back for most of the game deploys smartly.  They're fresh and eager for battle, while my weary troopers are getting worn down.

textbook assault into the flank of a worn-down Austrian battalion!  The kaiserlicks would evaporate after this gallant charge!

Ken sent as tactical advisor sent from the Archduke Himself.  General Dave looks at him bewildered.  "Who told the Archduke we needed any help here?"

Dave is hanging on by his fingernails, but holding back the fresh battalion in the village is a thing of genius, and therein lies the genius of Lasalle.  You can completely decide on the order you want to do things in.  Meaning you can carry out your plan, but the enemy gets a vote in your decision making.  You need to pick the right time to charge, to hang back, and you need to bring your artillery with you!  THe game feels like a well written history book, and it plays quickly.  

Not lighting fast, but if you have been reading my battle reports over the years you know that we rarely get to finish games.  I'll say this - we played through all 8 turns of the introductory scenario and they played faster as we went on.  We started at 1 and ended at 430 with a clear decision.

Speaking of decision - you're dying to know what happens eh?  My columns approached Eselbach through the cornfields east and north of the village.  THe Austrians were able to re-orient their flank to fire on me.

The massed brigade moves into assault Eselbach!  Will they make it in time?

Assaulting the village

In heavy fighting my assault columns are beaten back on turn 8!  The game is over!  Hard-earned victory to the Austrians!  This was an excellent game and very much enjoyed by all of us.  We will most certainly play again for tactical battles, and it's even got me thinking about collecting a 15mm army to fight Ken's armies!  







15 comments:

  1. Replies
    1. Ha! I sold off a huge 15mm Bavarian Army already, most of which I painted...

      Delete
  2. Superb stuff - sounds like another Sam Mustafa classic

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Darren youd love this game. It's right up your alley.

      Delete
    2. Yes Steve - just reading the appendices of the pdf now: supremely refreshing. I love how Sam does not engage with needless complexity - these rules do look very good.

      Delete
  3. Your game looks great, Steve, and good to see you back to F2F gaming. Is a complete rules’ revamp really a second edition?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a really good point, Jonathan. Arguably, I guess if you retain something from the original, it's still the original??

      Delete
  4. Lovely looking game and one that seems like a ‘players’ game that has really grabbed the interest of your group - could this become your Napoleonic system of choice? Very interesting to see an author keep a title, but put out an update with different guts, I wonder where that leaves fans of the first edition? And of course when someone mentions La Salle now, one would have to reply ‘which one’!

    You may have talked me into getting this. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Norm. I think for my part, I prefer the scale of "Blucher" for my Napoleonic battles but this is a very fun and innovative system as it pertains to the initiative and player actions. You would dig these rules, I think. My group really liked them and I know Ken played the first edition and didnt care much for it. I think it's worth having in your collection and no, I'm not a paid sponsor! :)

      Delete
  5. Interesting that it is a full rehash, must pick them up to have a look

    cheers
    Matt

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good to hear from you, Matt! Yes it's a wonderful game which we enjoyed very much. I've never played the first edition but I did read it.

      Delete
  6. Nice AAR and figures. L2 is an excellent fast play set with key decision points each turn. A lot is highly abstracted (skirmishing in particular) and combat/shooting is fairly bare bones but it all works seamlessly within the system and its just good plain fun. One can clearly see the influence of Blucher on new version. Another winner from Mr Mustafa.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers, Steiner, and completely agree. These are great rules and lots of fun to play. The abstraction really works and the game flows nicely. I like the skirmish mechanism as it impacts the battle narrative and enables the initiative. Probably better than fiddling with lots of smaller stands and doing mathematics!

      Delete
  7. That's an excellent game with some lovely photos, as you noted. It's always great to get a players view of a set of rules after actually playing them out. Thanks.
    Regards, James

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers James. Glad you enjoyed the batrep. I felt after playing these that a post was absolutely mandatory!

      Delete