This game brought to light some issues with morale, the question of adjudication of morale checks, and some other small issues that should be addressed prior to moving forward:
|Here they come, lads!!|
|And they came in the same, old way.|
The question of morale nagged me the whole time. When to check? How to check? Here's how it played out:
Whenever a unit takes a Strength Point Loss, it makes a Morale Check. The basic morale is the same number the Battalion makes to shoot and make saving throws. (all units in the game were regulars, so their basic morale is a 4+ on a 1D6.).
First question - since your troops are ordered to charge - do you make a pre charge morale check? Or dispense with the pre charge MC? I didn't do it as I saw it as an unnecessary, redundant penalty.
Then I thought that was too simple and probably unrealistic. So here's what I came up with this game - if morale was Shaken (yellow beads) or disorganized (black beads) you had to pass a morale check to carry out any movement. Shaken simply roll your morale and carry out operation. If you were disorganized, you could attempt to pass MC with a -1 modifier. If you pass, you move from Disorganized to Shaken.
Rally order simply removes all Shaken markers, and Disorganized becomes Shaken but the unit must remain stationary and cannot do anything else that turn.
I thought these were good compromises.
|Reeling after the first assault, French troops all shaken or disorganized.|
Onto the melee. So melee was handled just like shooting. Units attack with their SP dice, depending on how many they had. Therefore 2 beat up French Battalions, each with strength point "2" got 4 dice when attacking a fresh British Battalion that gets 4 dice. Worked out nicely this way, and I think handles multiple unit combats very neatly.
Loser of the melee retreats and loses 1 level of morale. If already disorganized, unit disintegrates REGARDLESS of strength points.
Disorganized is a very dangerous state for units to be in. A disorganized unit who fails a MC after melee is wiped out. A disorganized unit who fails a MC after shooting, loses 1 additional strength point. (does not count for rallying units, on rally orders. Failure just means they sit there as they were before they attempted to rally).
|French Division Commander considers his options...|
I like the artillery rules alot. The ranges are solid for the Napoleonic era and my 2 batteries were able to really bring the hurt onto the smaller hilltop, and effectively softened up the British Battalion prior to the ground troops assaulting it. Once contact was made, the roll of the artillery diminished considerably as the hills were masked by friendly troops. Long range these guns fired with 1 die. Effective range 2 dice. Close range 3 dice. Had the British had a battery in support, the game may have played out differently.
At some point I wished the British player would have had skirmishers to fire at the massed French columns cruising right towards their position but didn't think to include skirmishing in this game. Probably need to rethink that. (option with your Brigades or Regiments to detach a battalion to skirmishing duties, break it up into small stands, and work their way forward from the main body).
|Ahhh what the hell. DIVISION ADVANCE!|
Another problem revolved around timing of morale checks. Trying to remember to make a morale check in the morale phase was tough so I ended up taking MC's immediately after casualties were caused. In this way, I made sure I didn't forget. With 20 or 30 Battalions on the table, this kind of book-keeping would be tough, especially in the heat of battle!
If you HAD to have the Morale Checks in a separate phase, you could place a marker (casualty or skull & crossed bones etc) marker next to the lads as a reminder.
I marked casualties with red dice but casualty markers or stones would probably look much cooler now that I think about it.
|A different strategy this time - the French will advance in line and fire on the British.|
|New tactic works as another battered British Battalion leaves the field.|
|French occupy the small hill.|
Well a little choppy but otherwise a very fun and satisfying game, at least as much so as the original. I am looking forward to playing more of this and incorporating more units, cavalry, grand batteries and the like.
PS orders were given to individual battalions, not brigades as I had originally though. I have no idea how realistic this is, but it makes the game move faster and is probably more fun as it allows you to maneuver and fire.