BULLDOG SIX THIS IS ANVIL TWO THREE SALUTE REPORT TO FOLLOW *BREAK*
SIX TANGO-SEVEN TWO'S ADVANCING EAST OF AMBURG THROUGH THE VALLEY IN VICINITY OF PHASE LINE PHILS UNIT UNKNOWN AT ZERO SIX HUNDRED LOCAL HOW COPY OVER?
TANGO MIKE, ANVIL, BULLDOG COPIES ALL *BREAK* ALL BULLDOG ELEMENTS THIS IS BULLDOG SIX, ENEMY TANGO SEVEN TWO'S ADVANCING EAST OF AMBURG NEAR TANGO ROMEO PAPA ONE. STAND BY AND GOOD HUNTING, SIX OUT.
Ken came over this past weekend and we played our first game of Battlefront's "Team Yankee" before I had to go into work. Since then, I'd been jotting down some notes on my impressions of the game to include what I liked, what I didn't like, and, thanks to a question from David F, what makes it different from Sabre Squadron?
|The board. Modern roads, 20th century buildings and a bunch of Cold War forces!|
Forces we used were roughly even, with the US bringing 2 mech infantry platoons (M113) and 1 M1 Abrams tank platoon to the fight along with a FIST track, a howitzer platoon ("battery").
The Soviets had 4 T-72 "Companies" of 3 tanks each, along with a motor rifle company mounted in Ken's outstanding Battlefront BMP-1s. Like everyone else lately, we were forced to use some proxies to stand in until we get appropriate forces painted up. So T-80s stood in for T-72s, and in some cases, World War II US infantry stood in for additional modern US Infantry. Most of the US stuff however was already painted up and on the table.
I don't remember the points these forces totaled up to. We decided for ease of play, we would go with the "Free for All" mission. We diced for the attacker and the US player (me) won the dice off so the US were to be the attacking forces.
We placed platoons on the table, alternating one at a time. The M1's were centrally located, pointed straight at Ken's left flank objective and each infantry platoon was placed on a US flank. Ken placed his armor companies across a wide breadth and his infantry in the vicinity of the road, threatening the village.
|My Roskopf M109 Howitzers on the left. A 3 track US infantry platoon and the FIST track all on the US left flank|
|US right flank. The M577 track is the company commander. TY wants you to use a tank or APC for this but I couldn't resist!|
|Ken placing the Soviets. Note the US Armored Division objective marker on the small hill|
|Ken's Artillery with a ZSU standing in for a self propelled howitzer behind a Soviet tank company. The Larry Leadhead Mug lets you know we're hardcore gamers here!|
|German Panzer Division Objective marker east of the village.|
|Okay, board is ready to go!|
|Not an auspicious start to the war...|
|M1 sneaking around|
|US FIST Track moves cautiously up. Note all my specialist vehicles are painted in Summer MERDC. My line vehicles are painted in Winter MERDC.|
|Ken moves his BMPs up while my M1 sets up for a shot!|
|Pact armor pours into Germany!|
|Ken's BMPs on the road along with his command tank which is one of Ken's QRF T-64s.|
|US infantry finally reach the tree line. The woods themselves were a little over 8" wide, so I could have easily dismounted the infantry and moved them straight away, instead of ferrying them up to the line in their battle taxis.|
|M1 platoon positions itself to try and kill some BMPs and trade shots with the T-72s on the hill!|
|Meanwhile, the US Artillery is in firing positions and ready to assist! Note the Soviet objective marker. The US player opts to shell the small hill in front of the M1s.|
|Here's the massive Team Yankee template.|
|And here are my cool barrage markers.|
|Hit, Hit, and Hit. The Arty would kill 1 T-72 which I was OK with!|
|meanwhile Ken has plans of his own and surges the infantry forward into the town, way too close for comfort to my M1s|
|Soviet infantry occupy the pig sty and a gasthaus and bring fire down on an M1!|
|meanwhile, Ken's attack on his right is shaping up!|
|A badly positioned M109 takes a HEAT round....enough said!|
|US armor extricates itself from the town and goes after those T-72s on the hill! Both flanks are opening up now as both sides go for broke.|
|US Infantry deploy to block Ivan. But the M47 Dragon ATGM barely chips the paint on those T-72s!|
|note the bailed M1. I failed 2 or 3 turns in a row to remount...all you have to do is not roll a 1!|
|Ken's got a solid wall of infantry and armor advancing forward in the center and on his right.|
|Ken moves his infantry over to try and get some casualties against the US attack on his left.|
|Ivan redeploys to slow down those US tanks!|
|Since the FIST was obliterated but Soviet tank guns, the US Company Commander is bringing fire down on the Soviet infantry in the pig sty in the center.|
|Meanwhile the Redlegs are getting the worst of the Soviet fire!|
|US infantry on the US left break contact and head for the objective, desperate to hold the hill at all costs!|
|The M113 APCs on the US right spot a large concentration of Soviet infantry moving forward and fire all their on board MGs at them with telling results, KOing some teams and pinning them in place.|
|Even though Ivan's down on this flank, he's definitely not out! A SAGGER takes out a US M113 and only a Dragon team survives.|
|Securing the objective. On the US left flank, it's the opposite story where a hoard of Ken's tanks are threatening my infantry on the hill top. The US side meets its conditions, probably 1 turn before the Soviet side could and wins the game.|
I have to say I'm impressed with the Battlefront people for listening to their customers, and for developing a variation of Flames of War that feels more genuine (whatever that means), more flexible in terms of choices you can make during the game, and honestly feels like a modern game, and not like "world war 2 with bigger tanks." While Ken and I didn't play with all the toys in the Team Yankee arsenal, the sheer amount of hardware we had on the table was impressive compared to some of our Sabre Squadron games and these rules handled all of it with relative ease.
What I Liked
I think Team Yankee is less ambiguous than Flames of War (the new close combat / assault rules are refreshing, and hit allocation is also equally refreshing).
Modern equipment is very impressive, and these rules capture the vast capabilities your units bring to the table now (movement, range, stabilization, missiles, chobham armor), and strike an appropriate balance between various battlefield arms. Infantry are crucial and have their place, and the best weapon to kill tanks, so far, seems to be other tanks. I think the Soviets and their NATO opponents would agree on that in real life. Armor takes on its role as "the mounted combat arm of decision."
I like the idea of special orders that you can give to your force to allow them to get a local advantage, even if I never had an opportunity to use them.
Force seem to have an inherent "To Hit" now which I really like. Soviet units are hit on a 3+. US units are hit on a 4+.
Vehicles unbog themselves now!
I think Battlefront has done a very good job of producing a challenging modern game, and not necessarily a modified set of their World War II rules. That, in my humble opinion, was the biggest challenge of all. So well done there.
What I didn't Like
Ken and I both had a blast playing this so there isn't much I can say that I disliked.
The ranges and movement options are so extensive now that playing on a 6 x 4 table is probably not the way you want to go if you have more space. I found that I used tactical movement the entire game, with almost no need for any of the specialized movement orders.
Soviet Artillery is hard to get your hands on which I for one didn't like (personal preference). Even though it was a meeting engagement, Ken's artillery battery should have been blasting all my defensive positions instead of trying to make their roll to get into the fight. I understand the logic of a centralized, inflexible army calling for hasty fires, but still feel like the Soviets should have a slightly better chance of getting their artillery into the game.
Infantry have their place on the table, but it's probably best if they're rooting out and killing other infantry and staying the hell out of the tanks' way. So to me that seems like it would be very hard to win a game with an all-infantry or mostly infantry force. In this case, the US forces won with their tank platoon and not their mech. We didn't play with TOW missiles backing up the infantry so maybe that gives them the teeth they'll need? Other than that, I felt that my infantry were very vulnerable the entire game. (some could argue that's a strength of these rules???)
Compared to Sabre Squadron
Well David F asked me how TY compares to Sabre Squadron and interestingly I'm still having a hard time answering him. Look at the amount of units we had on the table, and were able to play a full game to completion in a few hours, and that was with rules questions and searching through only one rulebook.
Don't get me wrong here, I enjoy Sabre Squadron and will continue to play it, but I definitely want to play more games of Team Yankee. Its simplicity alone makes it a winner for a modern game (Third Generation Warfare, I'm looking squarely at you here...) and Sabre Squadron, while simple, still seems complex compared to Team Yankee now. And as everyone knows, I have less and less patience for bullsh*t or needless complexity with rules.
Well that's about it until I can think of some other things - Ken, did I miss anything?